Order within the next 23 hours and 27 minutes to ship Wednesday
Select an Optionexpand_more
Please select an option before adding to cart.

Select an Option:

Need Any Accessories?

Pro Soft Glove Conditioner

Pro Soft Glove Conditioner


EvoShield Catchers Thumb Guard

EvoShield Catchers Thumb Guard


Add to Cart expand_more
Place your order within the next 23 hours and 27 minutes and your order will ship out WEDNESDAY with FREE SHIPPING.


  • Fastpitch Softball Specific Pattern

  • Heavy Duty Lacing

  • Calf Tanned Leather Palm Lining

  • Oil-Softened Premium Steerhide Leather Shell

  • Reinforced Closed Web

  • Cool Max Finger Lining System - Keeps Hand Dry and Comfortable for Total Control

  • Velcro Back to Easily Adjust Size

  • Double Break Heel

  • Free Shipping!

  • 33.50 Inch Pattern

  • 100 Day Love Your Glove Guarantee



All Star has a solid commitment to innovation, advanced technology, outstanding craftsmanship and quality service that makes them one of the top manufacturers on the market! The All Star MVP Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt is strategically designed for the serious player looking to improve and enhance their skills and abilities. This line of mitts is designed to be game-ready so that players can hit the field almost instantly. This series offers Pre-Oiled Steer Hide Leather with a Calf Tanned Palm Lining for maximum comfort and protection. Players have never felt anything like this before, it's amazing! The All Star MVP Series features Heavy Duty Rawhide Laces for extreme strength and durability. This glove is built to last for many grueling games, seasons, and is perfectly constructed for the female hand! This model also offers a unique Cool Max Finger Lining System, which is designed to reduce moisture, and give players a cool, comfy feel every time. All Star: Built for the Stars Free Shipping!

Reviews (8)


Average Ratings Based on 8 Customer Reviews

Overall Rating
Post a Review
Overall Rating
Screaming coach

add_circle_outlinePros: It just feels right. Nothing cheap about it. No pleather and very strong lacing. Was a little hard to break in, but not too bad

remove_circle_outlineCons: Pocket could be deeper. My daughter is having a little bit of a hard time closing before the ball pops out.

Was this review helpful? thumb_up11 thumb_down3
Overall Rating

add_circle_outlinePros: Great glove, easy break to break in. Great pop.Lots of palm padding

remove_circle_outlineCons: Leather is very dry, have to oil two to three times a year

Was this review helpful? thumb_up3 thumb_down0
Overall Rating
Squirrel boy

add_circle_outlinePros: Great team catchers glove

remove_circle_outlineCons: Doesn't come broken in.

Was this review helpful? thumb_up2 thumb_down0
Overall Rating
Great Glove zues: parent

add_circle_outlinePros: great glove: after trying different gloves we found the right one; this glove was easy to break in and looks and feels great.

remove_circle_outlineCons: na

Was this review helpful? thumb_up0 thumb_down0
Overall Rating
Prep Dad

add_circle_outlinePros: Like the mitt. Not that many that are for lefty throwers. Seems like it is built for the long haul.

remove_circle_outlineCons: Taking longer than expected to break in. Leather does cry for lots of oil.

Was this review helpful? thumb_up0 thumb_down0
Overall Rating
all star mvp left handed catchers glove Tina parent

add_circle_outlinePros: nice glove, made to last nothing cheap about it my daughter loves it

remove_circle_outlineCons: hard to break in, we baked it, oiled it and had it steamed and beaten and still side are stiff, my daughter has a hard time with the ball popping out when catching

Was this review helpful? thumb_up0 thumb_down0
Overall Rating

add_circle_outlinePros: Fits well

remove_circle_outlineCons: The mitt is heavy for my 10U daughter and break in has been difficult. Oil is a must.

Was this review helpful? thumb_up0 thumb_down0
Overall Rating
Catchers Mom

add_circle_outlinePros: My daughter was excited to get this mitt. She loves All Star and wanted the catchers mitt to go with her All Star catchers gear. The mitt is very well constructed. It feels good on your hand. She is in 14U and up until now has just used her regular glove, but with fastpitch, her hand would get a little sore. You definitely do not have to worry about that with this mitt. It is good and thick.

remove_circle_outlineCons: The only con with this mitt is that we thought that "game ready" meant game ready... It actually took some breaking in and she has actually started using a Nokona mitt instead because she could not get this one broken in good. We tried steaming, oil, wraps, etc.... she slept with it under her mattress, yet it still did not break in well.

Was this review helpful? thumb_up0 thumb_down0
Show all 8 reviews of the All Star MVP Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW2510

Questions and Answers (5)


Have a question about the All Star MVP Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW2510? Ask our team of experts and they will respond within 24 hours.

Do you sell fast pitch catchers mitt that fits a mans hand I catch my daughter during lessons?
Unfortunately, all fastpitch mitts are designed to fit a smaller hand. I recommend a 13" baseball first base mitt. That's what my father always used when catching my sister from youth through High School.
Is this mitt light in its weight? Or what brand would feature a lighter weight catchers mitt?
I think that the All Star MVP Series: CMW2510 Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt is a good mixture of lightweight and high quality leather. All Star as a brand is known for making the best catchers mitts. I think this is a great option.
Would this glove be too big for an 11 year old girl?
softball mom
This All Star MVP Series (CMW2510 Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt) will have a 33.5" circumference that may be a little large for an 11 year old player at the start. However, if you were interested in getting a mitt into which she can grow with time, this mitt may work well for her.
My granddaughter is a backup catcher on her high school fastpitch softball team. She is 15 years old, 5'1" tall, and weighs 150 lbs. Would this mitt be a good fit for her?
The All Star catcher's mitts are some of our most popular models, so the All Star MVP Series: CMW2510 Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt would be a great option. Most high school catchers wear anywhere from 33.5" to 34.5" sizes, so the 33.5" size of this particular mitt should work well.
My daughter is going to be 2nd year 12u for 2019, the glove she used this year worked well however seems on the small side. Looking for a bit larger glove that breaks in easily, deep pocket, the ball pops out sometimes with the current glove. She is 5'2' with medium size hands.
The All Star MVP Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW2510 might be a bit too large and a little to stiff for your daughter currently. In the future the All Star MVP Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW2510 would be a great choice for a player looking for a more stiff, longer break in period.
Show all 5 Questions and Answers about the All Star MVP Series Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW2510
No results. If you searched for a specific term, please broaden your search. If you have already done this and still cannot find what you're looking for, please submit your question and we'll get back to you within 24 hours. Thanks!

About the Brand


Design Leadership: In the area of baseball protective products, All-Star's design leadership is unsurpassed. From batter's helmets to leg guards, All-Star holds many patents and has made numerous developments that have now become standard in the industry. Wraparound shins and triple knees on leg guards, lightweight wire masks, adjustable batter's helmets and sternum and collarbone protection in chest protectors are just a few of the many advancements made by All-Star.

Technology and R&D: All-Star's production facilities use the latest in manufacturing technology, including several patented manufacturing processes. All-Star invests heavily into the research and development of new products as well as the processes required to manufacture them.

Quality and Value: These are prime concerns of the retailer and consumer alike. With a defective rate of less then 1/10th of 1%, you can rest assured that once a customer buys an All-Star product the sale will be final. All-Star's products are designed to give the retailer and the consumer the quality and value they are looking for.

Glove Properties

Color Black
Color Brown
Feel Game Ready
Glove Type Female Fastpitch
Glove Type Softball
Position Catcher
Price $0 - $99.99
Size 33.50
Sub Type Catchers
Vendor All Star
Web Type Fully Closed

What Our Fans Are Saying

Very happy buying experience. will recommend to all my friends


Roseau, MN

View More Experiences

You can compare a maximum of four items.
Please remove one item to add another.
Add up to 4 items to compare.
Compare (0 of 4)expand_more Show Comparison